Bill Gray
All posts from Bill Gray
Bill Gray in Bill Gray,

14 stocks that hold up best at market highs

Here we go again. Stocks are bumping up against all-time highs. Investors are enjoying the ride, but are understandably worried they’ll be the ones to buy at the top.

Buying stocks at tops, of course, is a bad move since most stocks feel the pain. But if it’s any comfort, there are 14 stocks in the Standard & Poor’s 500, including ExxonMobil, Kellogg and lots of utilities like Wisconsin Energy and energy firms like Southwestern Energy, that have held up significantly better than the market during each and every one of the past three market peaks, according to a USA TODAY analysis of data from S&P Capital IQ.

To make the list, these stocks needed to outperform the S&P 500 by at least 15 percentage points during each  of the past three market downturns between the bull top and the bear bottoms as defined by S&P Capital IQ strategy expert Sam Stovall.

Look, no one wants to talk about market pullbacks when the market is ripping like it is now. Being conservative during bull markets can actually be costly if investors miss out on gains. But not being prepared for the inevitable pullback can be even more dangerous as investors see much of their bull market gains evaporate.

And that’s why, when everyone else is partying, it’s wise to at least know about stocks that have been almost Teflon-coated during downturns.

Below are the 14 S&P 500 stocks that beat the S&P 500 by at least 15 percentage points in each of the past three downturns:

CompanySymbol% ch. 7/16/1990-10/11/1990% ch. 3/24/2000-10/9/2002% ch. 10/9/2007-3/9/2009
Southwestern EnergySWN-3.7%68.4%26.5%
EOG ResourcesEOG8.4%80.7%-35.6%
Archer Dan. MidlandADM-2.8%30%-23.0%
Wisconsin EnergyWEC0.4%20.5%-21.0%
Anadarko PetroleumAPC2.2%29.5%-39.0%
Noble EnergyNBL1.5%11.7%-41.1%
Dominion ResourcesD0.6%-2.9%-38.4%
Duke EnergyDUK1.1%-33.8%-38.9%
S&P 500^SPX-19.9%-49.1%-56.8%

Source: S&P Capital IQ, USA TODAY, Sam Stovall

Take the example of Southwestern Energy,  a natural gas and oil exploration company. The stock fell just 3.7% between the market’s peak on July 16, 1990, and the ultimate bottom on Oct. 11, 1990. It’s a loss, true. But it’s much better than the 19.9% decline by the Standard & Poor’s 500 during the same time. Southwestern held up even better — gaining 68.4% — between the market high of March 24, 2000, through the bottom on Oct. 9, 2002. During that time, the market fell a crushing 49.1%. And most recently, Southwestern rose 26.5% between the Oct. 9, 2007, peak and the March 9, 2009, low, beating the S&P 500, which fell 57%.

Share this image:

Chart source: MSN Money

Energy is clearly an area that has held up well during the past downturns. Six of the 14 stocks are from the energy sector, including EOG Resources and Anadarko Petroleum. But utilities are equally represented, as six of the 14 stocks are from that sector, including Wisconsin Energy and Southern Company.

S&P Capital IQ, USA TODAY research via Microsoft Excel

Outside of the traditional defensive sectors, Archer Daniels Midland is a standout. The agriculture company posted an average 1.4% gain during past three bull-to-bear cycles. But Archer Daniels Midland is a good example of how during a vicious bear market, it’s very difficult to hide all the time. The stock only fell 2.8% in the 1990 decline and rose 30% in the 2000-2002 decline. But investors got nicked with a 23% hit in the 2007 to 2009 fall, albeit that’s much better than the overall market’s 56.8% fall during that time.

Chart source: MSN Money

There’s a huge caution. While these stocks have held up significantly better than the market, not one gained in each and every peak-to-trough period. And just three of the 14 stocks posted an average gain during the past three downturns.

And there’s no guarantee these stocks will hold up again if the market is about to fall. Bear markets usually have their own points of pain, and these companies may not be as insulated next time. But there will be a next time, and these stocks do have a good track record.

Below are the 14 S&P 500 stocks that topped the market by 15 percentage points or more during each of the market’s peaks that turned into bear markets (displaying average change over past three bear markets) :

CompanySymbolAverage % Ch. during past three bearsSector
Southwestern EnergySWN30.4%Energy
EOG ResourcesEOG17.8%Energy
Archer Daniels MidlandADM1.4%Consumer staples
Wisconsin EnergyWEC0.0%Utilities
Anadarko PetroleumAPC-2.4%Energy
Noble EnergyNBL-9.3%Energy
Dominion ResourcesD-13.6%Utilities
Duke EnergyDUK-23.8%Utilities
Standard & Poors’s 500-41.9%

Source: S&P Capital IQ, USA TODAY, Sam Stovall