Exxon has been a first choice for institutional investors because of its stable performance over the decades—and of course, its dividend policy. But times are changing, and investors today are paying more attention to climate change and a company’s preparedness for the seemingly unavoidable transition to a lower-carbon economy in most parts of the world.
The latest report from CDP should worry the top management of Exxon and that of its peer Chevron. It should worry them very much. One must adapt to survive— a fact that Old Spice, who effectively reinvented itself to keep up with the next generation, knows all too well.
The CDP is an organization that tracks environmental data from a variety of major companies, and supplies this data to a network of 827 large investors who have combined assets under management of
And we know that major investors and institutions are backing away from companies perceived as environmentally unfriendly—and oil seems to be taking the brunt of this
The CDP’s latest
This is rather bad or even a bit humiliating, given that even Brazil’s Petrobras, the mismanaged company with the biggest debt load in the industry, is ahead of both Exxon and Chevron, at number 7.
The top performers are, in descending order, Norway’s Statoil, Italian Eni, and French Total.
The 11 companies were rated in terms of their fossil fuel asset mix, which is why Statoil received such a high score – because it has the most gas in its overall mix, which is not nearly as frowned upon as its dirty cousin, oil.
Shell (at #4) also has a wealth of gas reserves after the acquisition of BG Group, as does BP, which is why it’s been ranked at #5.
The other metrics that defined the final score were capital flexibility, climate governance and strategy, emissions and resource management, and water resilience, the latter referring to a company’s exposure to water stress problems, which, says the CDP, could halt production or increase costs.
Based on these metrics, Exxon and Chevron are not managing their upstream business very efficiently, according to the report—a finding that’s bound to give investors pause, which is not so good for the two companies, especially Exxon, which already was strong-armed by a group of investors to acknowledge even the existence of climate change and to provide a place on its board for a climate scientist.
According to the CDP, Exxon’s biggest problems have to do with emissions and climate governance and strategy, although in terms of capital flexibility, it scored better than others on the list.
Chevron, which, according to its website, last year scored
Gas, it seems, is a huge factor when ranking the energy supermajors on the list. Many see it as a bridge fuel between oil and zero-emission renewables, so the solid preparation for a lower-carbon economy logically includes growing their exposure to gas. Based on this, if the worst performers take heed of CDP’s findings, we might see some increased exploration and M&A activity in gas in the near future.
By Irina Slav for Oilprice.com
More Top Reads From Oilprice.com: