Motley Fool
0
All posts from Motley Fool
Motley Fool in Motley Fool,

Robo-Advisors: What They Cost, And What You Get

Over the past decade or so, robo-advisors – automated platforms that create and maintain diversified investment portfolios – have taken the financial advisory world by storm. With lower fees than traditional financial advisors, robo-advisors have surged in popularity and are expected to continue to grow over the next few years.

With that in mind, here's a rundown of the major players in the robo-advisory market, as well as a discussion of the features, perks, and costs that come with each.

Image Source: Getty Images.

Features and perks often offered by robo-advisors

As I mentioned, the general idea of a robo-advisor is a service that automatically creates a diversified portfolio for you, and then maintains (rebalances) the portfolio over time. So, it's safe to assume that all of the robo-advisory services discussed here do at least that much.

In addition, there are some other things to look for when selecting a robo-advisory service that may be important to you. Just to name some of the most common:

  • Tax strategies – If you invest in a taxable account, you are allowed to deduct an investment loss against your capital gains or even your ordinary income, a concept known as tax-loss harvesting. Many robo-advisory services will do this for you, sometimes included for all clients, and sometimes at an additional cost. This can be a major advantage in a taxable investment account.
  • Hybrid advisory model – In the pure sense of the term, a robo-advisory is an entirely automated process. However, "hybrid" models have emerged which include an automated portfolio management component as well as access to a real-live financial advisor. Some robo-advisories offer dedicated financial advisors for high-balance accounts.
  • Direct indexing – This means buying individual stocks to create a portfolio instead of funds. A couple of the robo-advisory services do this for accounts with high-balances. This has the effect of saving on fund fees, and also makes it easier to take advantage of tax strategies.
  • Proprietary or low-cost funds – Some robo-advisors charge lower management fees (or none at all) if they offer their own funds. Others simply use lower-cost index funds than competitors. With a robo-advisory, the management fee is only half of the cost structure. The underlying mutual funds and ETFs have their own fees, known as expense ratios.

List of major robo-advisors

There are many robo-advisory services on the market, and the industry is evolving rapidly. For that reason, this isn't necessarily an exhaustive list. Rather, this is just intended to be a list of some of the largest and most well-known robo-advisors, and a brief discussion of the features of each (see the list of features in the previous section for descriptions). After the list is a table comparing fees and account minimums for each service.

Wealthfront – Wealthfront and Betterment are the two pioneers in the robo-advisory world. Wealthfront manages the first $10,000 of clients' assets for free and charges a 0.25% fee after that. The service offers daily tax-loss harvesting for all taxable accounts and has a direct indexing servicing for balances of $100,000 or more.

Betterment – Betterment offers up to 1 year of free management, and a 0.25% standard fee on an ongoing basis. For customers who want a hybrid model and have at least $100,000 to invest, Betterment Premium is available with a 0.40% management fee that includes phone advisor access.

Wealthsimple – The thing that makes Wealthsimple unique is that it offers socially responsible investment portfolios. The platform offers free tax-loss harvesting, and has a two-tiered fee stricture: 0.5% fee on balances $100k or less and 0.4% on balances above $100k.

WiseBanyan – Calls itself the "world's first free financial advisor," and the basic robo-advisory service doesn't have a fee, although there are still underlying fund expense ratios. WiseBanyan charges 0.25% if customers want tax-loss harvesting, with a cap of a $20 monthly fee.

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios – Schwab offers two variations of its robo-advisory service, and this is the free one. Schwab can afford to do this, as it makes money by investing client assets in its own funds. Tax-loss harvesting is offered on taxable account balances of $50,000 or more.

Vanguard Personal Advisor Services – This is the largest robo-advisory service in the market by far. It is a hybrid model that includes unlimited access to financial advisors (CFPs). Investing over $500,000 gets you a dedicated financial advisor. Vanguard's appeal is the low-cost structure of its funds, and because of this, its all-in cost is among the lowest of hybrid robo-advisors.

Schwab Intelligent Advisory – Schwab's hybrid robo-advisory product offers lower management fees and lower account minimums than Vanguard. Tax-loss harvesting is free with $50k minimum balance. As a hybrid robo-advisory, clients get unlimited appointments with CFPs.

Personal Capital – Uses individual securities in accounts with $200k, which maximizes tax-loss harvesting. Standard fee is 0.89%, but accounts over $1 million get discounted pricing. Average expense ratio is 0.09%. All accounts have access to a team of financial advisors, and get tax-loss harvesting services, and clients with $200k or more get two dedicated advisors to call, email, or video chat.

Wells Fargo Intuitive Investor– Discounted 0.40% fee with $25k in deposits or $50k in combined balances. Investment options include BlackRock iShares ETFs and some smart-beta products by Goldman Sachs. There are still several unknown factors about Wells Fargo's robo-advisory, since it was just recently announced.

Fidelity Go – The most unique aspect of Fidelity's robo-advisory is its all-in investment fee that includes fund expenses – 0.35% for retirement portfolios and 0.40% for taxable accounts. The service uses Fidelity index funds, but taxable portfolios add BlackRock iShares ETFs. Tax-loss harvesting is not offered.

TDAmeritrade Essential Portfolios – TD Ameritrade's robo-advisory service offers free tax-loss harvesting, and its fund expense ratios of 0.06%-0.08% are among the lowest in the business.

E*Trade Adaptive Portfolio – E*Trade's robo-advisory offers clients a choice between a portfolio of mutual funds and ETFs, or a portfolio made up entirely of ETFs. The hybrid mutual fund and ETF portfolio option has underlying fund fees 0.20%-0.45%, while the all-ETF portfolio's fees are 0.20%, in addition to the management fee. Unlike many of the others, E*Trade does not offer tax-loss harvesting strategies.

Robo-Advisor

Investment Fees

Fund Fees (Average)

All-In Cost

Account Minimum

Assets Under Management

Wealthfront

0.25%

0.12%

0.37%

$500

$7.5 billion

Betterment

0.25%-0.40%

0.09%-0.17%

0.34%-0.57%

$0

$10 billion

Wealthsimple

0.40%-0.50%

0.1%-0.26%

0.5%-0.76%

$0

$1 billion

WiseBanyan

0%-0.25%

0.12%

0.12%-0.37%

$0

$100 million

Schwab Intelligent Portfolios

0%

0.07%-0.21%

0.07%-0.21%

$5,000

$24 billion**

Vanguard Personal Advisor Services

0.30%

0.05%-0.19%

0.35%-0.49%

$50,000

$83 billion

Schwab Intelligent Advisory

0.28%

0.07%-0.12%

0.35%-0.40%

$25,000

$24 billion **

Personal Capital

0.49%-0.89%

0.09%

0.58%-0.98%

$100,000

$5 billion

Fidelity Go

0.35%-0.40%*

N/A

0.35%-0.40%

$5,000

Unknown

Wells Fargo Intuitive Investor

0.40%-0.50%

Unknown

Unknown

$10,000

N/A

E*Trade Adaptive Portfolio

0.30%

0.20%-0.45%

0.50%-0.75%

$5,000

$180 million

TDAmeritrade Essential Portfolios

0.30%

0.06%-0.08%

0.36%-0.38%

$5,000

$16 billion

Source: Each company's website, and NerdWallet reviews.  Assets under management is as of the latest available data for each company or service. *Fidelity's investment fee includes the expenses of the underlying funds. **Schwab AUM figure is for both robo-advisory services combined.

The bottom line on robo-advisors

Robo-advisors can be an excellent choice for investors who want a diversified portfolio that rebalances over time, but don't need or want the services of a human financial advisor. Different services have different benefits and drawbacks that should be taken into account when trying to find the best robo-advisor for you.

The $16,122 Social Security bonus most retirees completely overlook
If you're like most Americans, you're a few years (or more) behind on your retirement savings. But a handful of little-known "Social Security secrets" could help ensure a boost in your retirement income. For example: one easy trick could pay you as much as $16,122 more... each year! Once you learn how to maximize your Social Security benefits, we think you could retire confidently with the peace of mind we're all after. Simply click here to discover how to learn more about these strategies.

Matthew Frankel has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.